Comparison of Horizontal and Vertical axis tidal turbine with a new design to the renewable energy production of marine currents

Document Type : Original Article


1 Department of Marine industries, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran,

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Marine industries, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

3 Associate Professor, Department of Power electric, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.


This study is a new design of a vertical axis turbine that generates renewable energy from low-speed currents tidal. Tidal Energy is one of the most important available resources among the renewable and environmentally friendly energy resources in oceans and seas. Tidal turbines are used to produce renewable energy. Some types of tidal turbines widely used and studied are vertical axis tidal turbines (VATT) such as Savonius, Darrieus, Gorlov, Lucid, etc., in which the flow direction is not essential for them. And some types of tidal turbines are Horizontal axis tidal turbines (HATT) which the flow direction is important and often have good performance than vertical axis turbines. These turbines are well suited for absorption of high-speed current, but most ocean areas have tidal flow at low speed. The main purpose of this research is a numerical study of tidal turbines with a horizontal and vertical axis rotor and designing and modeling VATT to increase the power efficiency in low-speed currents. In numerical modeling, the HATT at high speeds has high efficiency, and CP to TSR is more than 0.4, but with the design of the vertical Savonius turbine, with the focus of the flow on the concave blade and the removal of force from the convex blade, almost equality in speed Less than 2m/s. In the modern design of the Savonius turbine, the ratio of CP to TSR has been increased three times and reaches more than 0.3 in compare the simple Savonius classic turbine. Therefore, due to advantages such as easier installation and lower maintenance costs of Savonius turbines, and with the new design, the use of these turbines in renewable energy will be appropriate.


[1] Lawn, C. J., (2009), Technologies for Tomorrow Electric Power Generation, Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science. Vol. 223
[2] Neill, S. and Hashemi M, Reza., (2018), Fundamentals of Ocean Renewable Energy, Since direct.
[3] Roberts, B., Thomas, P., Sewell, Z., Khan, S., Balmain, Z. and Khan, J. G., (2016), Current tidal power technologies and their suitability for applications in coastal and marine areas, Ocean engineer, Vol.2, p. 227- 245.
[4] Ketabdari, M j. and Solymani, Kaveh., (1394), Types of energy extraction methods of wave and tidal and effect on sea environmental, 2th International Offshore Industries Conference, Tehran.
[5] Shadman, M, Silva, C., Faller, D. and Wu, Z., (2019), Ocean Renewable Energy Potential, Technologyand Deployments a Case Study of Brazil, energies, Vol.12.
[6] Samadi, M., Ghodsi, M.H. nad Mozafari, B., (2019), Energy production potential of Qeshm channel tidal current extraction with CFD modeling of a tidal turbine, 8th International Conference, Tehran, sanatisharif university, Vol.8.
[7] Kadiri,M., Ahmadian, R., Bockelmann-Evans, B., Rauen, W. and Falconer, R., (2012), A review of the potential water quality impacts of tidal renewable energy systems, Renewable and sustainable energy reviews, Vol 16(1), p. 329-341
[8] Saini, G. and Prasad Saini, R P., (2019), A review on technology, configurations, and performance of cross-flow hydrokinetic turbines, Energy research, Vol.41, p. 79-88.
[9] Pallotta, A., Pietrogiacomi, D. and Romano, G.P., (2019), HYBRI - A combined Savonius-Darrieus wind turbine: Performances and flow fields, Energy, Vol.116, p.433-452
[10] Khan, M. J., Bhuyan, G., Iqbal, M.T. and Quaicoe, J.E., (2009), Hydrokinetic energy conversion systems and assessment of horizontal and vertical axis turbines for river and tidal applications: A technology status review, Applied Energy Vol.86, p.1823–1835.
[11] Satrio, Dendy., Pria Utama, I.K.A. and Mokhatasor., (2016), Vertical Axis Tidal Current Turbine Advantages and Challenges Review, Proceeding of Ocean, Mechanical and Aerospace, Vol.3, p. 64-71.
[12] Libii, J.N., (2013), Comparing the calculated coefficients of performance of a class of wind turbines that produce power between 330 kW and 7,500 kW, World Transactions on Engineering and Technology Education, Vol.11, p. 36-40.
[13] Nachtane, M., Tarfaoui, M., Goda, I. and Rouway, M., (2020), A review on the technologies, design considerations and numerical models of tidal current turbines, Renew energy, Vol. 157, p.127-164.
[14] Qian, P., Feng, B.H., Liu, X., Tian, Y. and Zhang, D., (2019), Review on configuration and control methods of tidal current turbines, Renew and Sustainable. Energy, Vol.108, p. 125-139.
[15] Zhou, W., Li, H., Liu, H., Lin, Y., Xu, Q., (2016), Review on the blade design technologies of tidal current turbine, Renewable and sustainable. Energy. reviews, Vol.63, p. 414-422.
[16] Payambarpour Abdolkarim S.A., Najafi, F. and Magagnato, F., (2020), Investigation of deflector geometry and turbine aspect ratio effect on 3D modified in-pipe hydro Savonius turbine: Parametric study, Renew. Energy, Vol.148, p. 44-59
[17] Gorle, J.M.R., Chatellier, L. and F. Pons., (2019), Modulated circulation control around the blades of a vertical axis hydrokinetic turbine for flow control and improved performance, Renewable and sustainable. Energy. reviews V.105, p. 363-377.
[18] Kerikous, E., and Thevenin, D., (2019), Optimal shape of thick blades for a hydraulic Savonius turbine, Renew. energy V.134, p. 629-638.
[19] Elbatran, A.H, Ahmed Y. M and Shehata, A.S., (2018), Performance study of ducted nozzle Savonius water turbine, comparison with conventional Savonius turbine, Energy, Vol.114, p. 566-584.
[20] Derakhshani, S., Ashori M. and Salemi., (2017), Experimental and numerical study of a vertical axis tidal turbine performance, Ocean Enginer, Vol.137, p. 59-67.
[21] Edon, M., (2007), 38-meter wind turbine blade design, Internship Report. Universite of Savoie.
[22] Chen, C.C, Choi, Y.D. and Yoon, H Y., (2013), Blade design and performance analysis on the horizontal axis tidal current turbine for low water level channel, 6th conference on Pumps and Fans with Compressors and Wind Turbines.
[23] Ghasemzadeh, F. 2013. Simulation of hydraulic problems in Flow-3D (2th Ed.), Noavar Press, Tehran, Iran.
[24] White, F.M, (2008), Fluid mechanics, publish, Mc graw hill education.
[25] Alizadeh, H., Jahangir, M.H. and ghasempour, R., (2020), CFD-based improvement of Savonius type hydrokinetic turbine using optimized barrier at the low-speed flows, Ocean engineering Vol.202, p. 171-178.
[26] Bhuyan, S. and Biswas, A., (2014), Investigations on self-starting and performance characteristics of simple H and hybrid H-Savonius vertical axis wind rotors, energy converstion and manegment, Vol.87, p. 859-867.
[27] Bin Yaakob, O., Tawi, K.B. and Suprayogi Sunanto, D.T., (2010), Computer Simulation Studies on the Effect Overlap Ratio for Savonius Type Vertical Axis Marine Current Turbine, IJE Transactions A: Basics, Vol. 23, p. 79-88.
[28] Tian, W., Zhaoyong, M., Zhang, B. and Li, Y., (2018), Shape optimization of a Savonius wind rotor with different convex and concave sides, Renewable Energy, Vol. 117, p. 287-299.